Dave Portnoy vs. 50 Top Pizza: Who’s the Real Slice King

Do Italians and Barstool agree on what makes the best pizza in America?

In this episode, I dive headfirst into the melty, saucy world of the 50 Top Pizza USA 2025 list — that’s right, the official ranking from Italy’s most respected pizza judges. But here’s the twist: I cross-checked every single one of them with One Bite’s pizza reviews from Dave Portnoy. Because who better to hold a pizza accountable than the guy who’s taken “just one bite” thousands of times?

 

Some pizzerias shine in both worlds. Others? Not so much.

You’ll hear which of these “Top 50” spots Dave has actually reviewed, and — spoiler — let’s just say he wasn’t always generous with the scores.

 

If you’re a pizza purist, a Dave Portnoy disciple, or just someone who’s hungry and doesn’t want to get burned by the hype, this episode’s for you.

Come for the sauce. Stay for the drama. 🍕

 

If you ever want to buy or sell a property anywhere in the world, our team would be honored to help get you to your next destination.

 

Until next time, stay curious, stay hungry, and as always… stay ALL IN!

 

Amit Bhuta
COMPASS
ALL IN Miami Group
Licensed Real Estate Agent

 

📱 (305) 439-3031 Mobile
📧 amit.bhuta@compass.com
🌎 ALLinMiami.com